Breaking News
Local News

New information emerges as families mark 19 years since Specht-Leonard killings

By Brian Carson 4 min read

LEWISTOWN -- Jason Specht's daughter is 35 now, two years older than her father ever got to be. She made the comparison during a recent meeting with investigators at the state police barracks, her uncle Eric Specht said.

Sherry Jo Leonard's youngest daughter was 8 when her mother died. She now has four daughters of her own.

Ahead of the 19th anniversary of the killings of Specht and Leonard, relatives met online again. Eric read a written statement from Mifflin County District Attorney Christopher Torquato that included an investigative update but few details.

"New information has been obtained as a result of these efforts," Torquato wrote.

The statement didn't describe what investigators had obtained or say when they obtained it. "Investigators remain convinced there are additional individuals who are able to provide further critical details," Torquato added.

Pennsylvania State Police Trooper Zeb Evans is investigating with assistance from county Detective Isaac Suydam. Both declined to comment, citing the ongoing investigation.

Firefighters found Leonard and Specht inside a mobile home along Route 522 in Granville Township after a fire was reported early on Nov. 25, 2007. Leonard, 43, was pronounced dead at the scene. Specht, 33, died at the hospital. Authorities ruled both deaths homicides.

In November 2025, Torquato told the families he'd asked Suydam to review the case from the beginning, including the evidence and witness statements, and look for other people to interview. Repeated tests on the physical evidence had produced inconclusive results, he said. The families also learned then that state police had assigned Evans to the case.

Eric's father and stepmother attended the recent meeting at the barracks. They don't usually take part in the online gatherings, he said. Investigators have stayed in touch with relatives between meetings, and Eric said both families are careful about what they say in public while the work continues. He wanted people to hear Torquato's appeal.

"We've not forgotten, and we're not finished, and we're not going away," Eric said.

Eric hopes his parents live to see the case solved. His grandmother is 99 and still talks about Jason and how long the family has waited for answers. Eric thinks about the time his brother has missed with his grandchildren. He still catches himself wondering what Jason would've said or done in moments that have nothing to do with the case.

When the online conversation turned to photographs of Sherry, her sisters remembered getting family pictures taken at Greenwood Furnace. They recalled sitting on hay bales and holding an umbrella over the photographer. Sherry had insisted that her family go first, her sister Stephanie Stains said. The picture was finished before the rain started. Stephanie's family was photographed in the rain.

Stains said she and her sisters depend on each other more since Sherry died. Each knows what November is like for the others. "I can't imagine life without my sisters because they know what it's like to lose a sibling," she said.

Memories of Jason often arrive with laughter. Eric remembers trying to have a serious conversation with someone and making the mistake of looking over at his brother. Jason would gesture to get him to laugh. He sent jokes by email, too, and Eric learned to wait until he was away from work to open them.

For Corey Specht, a Michigan football game can bring Jason to mind. At Thanksgiving, he remembers Jason at the table joking about the lumpy mashed potatoes. "Anybody that knew Jason knew he was the life of the party," Corey said. "He could tell a story 20 different times, and it would still make you laugh as if you heard it the first time."

Those memories come up more often as Thanksgiving approaches, Corey said. "But every single day, I think of Jason."

Stains looks forward to the day the two families can gather to celebrate. For now, relatives urge anyone who knows something about the killings to come forward. People in Mifflin County continue to ask family members what they've heard.

Eric hears those questions at Walmart often enough that he knows how the conversation usually starts. Someone will tell him they hate to bring it up, then ask about the case. He welcomes the questions. "It's still in the back of people's minds around the area," Eric said.

Torquato asked anyone with information about the killings to call Evans at the state police Lewistown station at 717-320-1010. People can also call Suydam at the Mifflin County District Attorney's Office at (717) 248-9800.

Starting at /week.